Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

KiteLife Forum

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Issue 10 (Jul/Aug 1999): BORK - Buggies and Foils

Featured Replies

This month was a busy one with several notable flame wars. You won't find any of that junk on the following pages. After all this is the BEST of Rec.Kites - Thanks to everyone who makes positive contributions to the Newsgroup.

Once again I'm indebted to the faithful BORK staff:

  • Craig Rodgerson
  • Peter C. Hugger Editor

This page is a summary of postings on the rec.kites Usenet news group that our editors believe to be interesting and useful.

Opinions expressed in these postings are not those of KiteLife Magazine or its staff.

NOTE: There are a number of ASCII illustrations below which may not appear correctly in this font, you may need to copy them into a text editor and apply a fixed-width font for everything to show accurately. More info on ASCII art here.


Buggies and Foils Contents:

  • Opinions
  • Selection
  • Addicted
  • Perfect Skin
  • Foil Design
  • Engineering
  • AntiBanana


Opinions

Interested in my opinion?

Buggys are my life! (Not a "com")

Both buggys are designed and built by Peter Lynn or at least under his aegis.

The biggest difference (other than a bit of geometry) is a matter of personal ergonomics.

I fail to understand how that criterea can be termed "better" or "worse" as it is a matter of personal preference.

I suggest you sit in both (and run them for a day or two if possible) and choose the one that is the most comfortable.

Both are excellent buggys. I do not see how you can make a mistake here.

That's about as staight forward as it gets.

aoxo [email protected]

=============================================================

Good Advice from Corey. Try 'em out.

Myself, being rather narrow in the rear, I prefer the Cobra which has a much narrower seat. (I'm 5'9", 148 pounds) ((Tight ass, good pecks, washboard gut, can press 2x body weight; if there are any available kiteflier women reading this!!!)) Not to mention any names, many buggiers are much wider at the posterior end and find the Cobra buggy to be far too, shall we say, constricting. The more fitting seat, for me, makes it so that I don't have to shift my weight, what little there is, up and over to bear into the opposite side (meaning into the hard side rail) to make an opposite tack. I've buggied on most of the different buggies but for my size the Cobra seat is the most comfortable. I can simply lean the other way when I turn.

The best condition, I think, would be for buggy manufacturers to offer, say, three different seat sizes for each model. That would offer the best and most comfortable situation for most any size of buggier. The PL Comp seats tend to conform, after a while, to individual proportions, a great improvement.

Now, see Corey, I didn't diride the seated size of anyone. Did I? :-)

It's really whatever's comfortable for yourself.

=============================================================

> dont be put off by the new low prices they are mostly do to increase in > production. not lowering the quality of materials. I love my comp others love > their sport flexie

Contrary to my long review of the flexi sport buggy a while back, I'm quite dissatisfied with it. After 5 trips to the desert, and no buggy jumping, it has already begun bending. The back wheels are leaning inward. And there is no way to turn anything over to bend the other way (like the Comp buggy).

I approached the distributors of the buggy here in the states (the Merry's), and they told me tough. Sorry, nothing we can do about it. That's the way it goes.

Needless to say, I am quite disappointed with their customer support (Cobra Kites). No more flexi products, a PL Comp it will be next time.

-- Steve Bateman


Selection

I do not own a buggy and have never flown a traction kite. From what I've read on the web it's better to start of with a small kite. I am very interested in Seattle airgear's kites. Especially the Wind Dance 3. Does anyone out there own one?

=============================================================

The WD series of foils are fun for tooting around in two-line barely- standing-up-on-your-feet mode; the pull is quite invigorating for one's first exposure, particularly in the higher winds with the larger WD2 and especially the WD 3 . However, as a traction kite, it might be okay for rollerblading in a parking lot, in fact probably quite a blast. In the conditions you cite, however, in soft sand with a buggy, I'm afraid that there would be a rather severe power shortage. To put it in perspective, according to the Quadrifoil specs the smallest of the Q 2000 series, the 2002, is rated at about 16 square feet, about 15% larger than the largest of the WindDances, and, I suspect, considerably more efficient a foil. Quadrifoil's entry-level Q 2002 "...can be used for traction purposes with roller blades, ice skates, or in higher winds as a standard foil for smaller, lighter weight flyers or larger flyers in strong winds..." according to material at its website.

So, for a good time in a big wind dragging your butt, goferit on the WindDances; as a buggy engine, the WD's are ummm...

Btw, I do own all 3 sizes of WD, and like 'em a lot for what they are. And I was out tonight in moderate winds getting my butt *really* dragged with a Q2003 that I'm training myself on :ani_yahoo:

Hoo-Wee!

Michael


Addicted

Last Saturday, I had the opportunity to (finally) get my butt attached to a kite buggy, under the auspices of Corey Jensen, and courtesy of Wind Power Sports here in Las Vegas. (no COM required, I hope, just giving credit where credit is due: I'm sure that similar demo's and instruction are available through any of the many fine traction kite and buggy equipment dealers out there, nationwide.)

I submit this posting just for the benefit of any others out there who have toyed with the idea of trying their hand at kite buggying, and who maybe regard this sport as perhaps dangerous, physically taxing, difficult to learn, whatever.

After a suit-up of appropriate safety gear, to include helmet, gloves, and knee- and elbow-pads, I received an excellent preparatory run-down of the methods and cautions associated with flying the kite and positioning the buggy for take-off, what to do if overpowered by the kite (LET GO!), and some anecdotal embellishments which only could come from someone as long in the tooth and eloquent of articulation as the esteemed Mr. Jensen. (hoo, boy, roll up yer pantlegs!)

Further instruction followed, regarding the methods of tacking upwind, how to de-power the sail for turns or just plain stopping, and the necessary precautions about "braking" the kite, versus braking the buggy (which, of course, has no brakes). A few words about where NOT to place your hands and/or feet, to avoid running over your own appendages. All of this took less than 30 minutes.

At first, in winds of 16-18, gusting to 20, I began my first attempt at buggying with a 2-meter Quadrifoil, and quickly began to feel frightened by the power of the kite, and uncomfortable with my ability to control the thing from the buggy. I went back and obtained a smaller, 1-meter sail, and tried again. Within minutes, I was tracking across the Ivanpah dry lakebed, and was able to concentrate on learning to steer, tack, and position the kite properly for the desired amount of speed. I later went back to a 2-meter kite, once I was comfortable with the increased power.

By the end of a single afternoon, I was flat screaming along on the buggy, (it feels a lot faster than actual speed), and was able to tack upwind or reach downwind feeling relatively safe and in control, and could even motor right back into "camp", stop, park my kite, and de-buggy, without assistance. It is easy, it is an adrenaline high, it is, above all, incredibly fun, and an experience not to be missed.

To sum up: If you're considering this sport, don't hesitate to give it a try, but seek out the advice of an expert, through your local equipment dealer or club. Ask for a demo ride, with proper equipment and instruction, and start slow.... use a small kite, the smallest that will pull you in the current conditions, and spend some time getting the "feel" of sailing with a mobile sail.

Thanks, Corey, for a wonderful day and a safe and delightful first buggy experience... I had heard you were noted for your phenominal ability to handle "virgins" with aplomb, and behold, I am deflowered without injury, and now examining my ruined bank book for the scrapings required to obtain a rig.

I gotta buggy till I fry, and soon!


Perfect Skin

Hi. I thought, in the spirit of sharing design information, I'd drop a message on designing shaped skins for power kites. This information is primarily aimed at those designing single skin kites, but is applicable to ram-air inflated kites too.

** WARNING ** This post contains crapscii™ graphics and is best viewed with a fixed width font.

** ADDITIONAL WARNING ** This post also contains math, including (Eeeagh!) trigonometry. If you are of a nervous disposition, go no further.

So, with no further ado, here we go.

The problem -----------

Consider a 'traditional' ram-air inflated foil. The sections of cloth between ribs are rectangular. Putting it another way, if you inflate the foil, it will naturally lay flat, and relies on its bridle to give it its 'arch' form whilst flying.

If we assume that the arch of the kite forms a part of a circle, it can be seen that the very top and very bottom of the kite's skin will fall on circles of differing radii. The points inbetween will fall somewhere inbetween. It can also be seen that the ribs as you approach the ends of the kite will tend to lean 'inwards'. This is perfectly natural, as we have, in effect, reduced the span of the upper skin with respect to the lower skin.

Graphic number 1 - tip of a standard ram air inflated foil viewed from the front.

Imagine this 'curved' around the foil's 'arch'. It is at this point I wish I had a drawing package available for Usenet.

		  Upper Skin
+---------------------------
/ / | |
/ | | |
/ / / /
+-------------------------------
Lower Skin

Ribs - Note increasing 'lean'

as we approach the tip

It can also be seen that the points on the skin between the absolute upper and lower points will be stretched away from their originally intended positions, placing additional stress on the skin of the kite.

All of this leads to two main inefficiencies:

1: As you approach the tips, the foil shape flattens, due to the leaning effect on the ribs

2: Slackness and unintended stresses will appear across the skin of the kite, most noticeably at the leading edge where the change in radius happens relatively fast. This will most likely manifest itself as additional drag, and, as a bonus, it will be most pronounced where we need it least. Bah.

For a cellular, ram-air foil, where the internal structure and shape is provided by ribs, this is not too much of a problem. It would be desirable to reduce the second as much as possible, although more drag could probably be reduced by improving (i.e. reducing the amount of) the bridling, and eliminating this is possibly more effort than it's worth.

HOWEVER, for a single skin foil, these problems become critical. Without structure to hold the shape, the skin will tend to a single sheet, flapping in the breeze. Even with structure and bridling, the leading edge will tend to be loose, flapping around and creating an immense amount of drag. For a single skin foil, we NEED to eliminate the problems described above. The solution I propose has the added benefit of causing the skin to billow naturally to the foil shape designed for the kite.

So. How do we do it?

Shaped Skin. the Theory. -------------------------

** FINAL WARNING ** This is where the math comes in.

First, a few assumptions.

1: We will not be trying to make the surface of the kite describe a smooth arc around the arch shape. Angles at intervals along the kite's surface interspersed with straight sections will suffice.

2: We wish the 'ribs' (or joints between sections) to run perpendicular to the shape of the arch (In plain english, we want the ribs to stand up straight)

3: We don't mind some wastage during manufacture to get the perfect skin, we don't mind some extra, intricate, sewing and we are a perfectionist.

First off, we need to calculate the shape that the skin needs to be.

Diagram 2 - an extreme example.

	  Upper Skin
------------+.................
/ \ .
/ \ .
/Rib \. Angle theta
--------+ \
Lower \ \
Skin \ \

Now, it can be seen from the above diagram that the upper skin (at the extreme) is longer than the lower skin. Now for the fun part. The difference between the upper and lower skins at a given point along the chord is proportional to the height of the foil shape or rib at that point along the chord. In fact, the difference can be given by the following equation.

d = r sin(t/2) where d is the difference at a position along the chord, r is the height of the rib at a position along the chord and t is the angle theta.

So. We can feed this into a spreadsheet and get the shape of the skin, eh? Not quite.

Shaped Skin - The Practice. ---------------------------

Well, before we start, we're going to need some tools. First off, your favourite spreadsheet. And, if possible, a copy of plotfoil, avaialble from http://www.drones.co....air/index.html among other places. Plotfoil will make the process much easier, believe me.

If you don't have plotfoil, or can't be bothered to use it, or something, head over to http://amber.aae.uiu...d_database.html, choose yourself an airfoil shape, and download the co-ordinates. If you have plotfoil, the airfoil co-ordinates should all be there.

Now, you have everything you need.

First, import the co-ordinates into your spreadsheet.

For EACH rib/joint, you will need to do the following:

Now, work out the width of skin required to cover the foil. For a single-skin kite, only calculate the upper skin, for a cellular foil calculate both skins. The calculation is derived from Pythagoras - calculate the length of the line between each pair of adjacent co-ordinates as follows - d = sqrt(((x2 -x1)^2)+((y2-y1)^2)) Add each of these up cumulatively and you will have a new set of 'x' values for the co-ordinates, and a total length.

multiply the total length by the final chord you want. This number is the depth of the skin (front to back).

Decide what angle 't' you want to 'bend' the kite by at the rib.

For each of the original 'y' co-ordinates, y2 = y*sin(t/2)

Export the new 'x' and 'y' co-ordinates as text, and use them as input to plotfoil. Use plotfoil to produce a template for the relevant chord length. this template will be laid along the side of the fabric to give the shape of the panel

Now, cut your fabric.

Assuming a consistent chord, the fabric panels will look something like this (rather overstated) diagram.

Diagram 3 - A panel, sorta.

		   Leading Edge
+----------------+
/. .\
/ . . \
| . . |
| . . |
| . . |
| . . |
| . . |
| . . |
|. .|
|. .|
|. .|
+----------------+

Where the dotted line is the standard 'square' panel outline.

Don't worry if the additional side sections seem really small - a tiny amount can create a huge difference in skin shape.

Anyway, sew 'em all together and there you have it.

Hope this has been of some use to someone. I'll start putting this stuff together on a page as soon as my photos get scanned, which should be today, but I've heard that before.

Simon

=============================================================

Hoi, I am trying to understand the ins 'n outs of building single skins kites, but what i don't understand is: what is the effect of a projected skin?

=============================================================

Have a look at a rain gutter pipe for example(the metal ones that have been joined at angles where it kinks or change shape), you could argue that a straight pipe could have been bent to kink that way except it would wrinkle and fold on the inside of the bend where there is excess material and loose structural integrity. If it was a heavy pipe carrying lots of rainwater it could tear apart! Now you could imagine the parafoil skin to form such a tube with tapering edges and smaller inside diameters to the tip if you will. If that was bent, say due to the curvature of its inflight shape and the bridle you'd get ugly wrinkles and kinks where the excess fabric is compress or where the shape of the fabric is incorrect to allow such natural deformation.

The problem comes in because of those kinks, bulges and wrinkles. Not only do they produce non-aerodynamic qualities but the also cause stresses within the parafoil that threaten to tear it apart on impact or in strong winds. Single skin hybrids aren't that much different from parafoils except that they only have topskins, but that is the nice part of it. You only have to do half the projection calculations.

=============================================================

If you use a projected skin your foil gets a natural arch, but what is the function of this arch (an easy bridle maybe? better flying qualities?). Or is a really stupid question, that every kite builder knows?

=============================================================

Skin prejection concerns the aerodynamic shape of the foil when it is arched and when the planform tapers with different sized profiles. The arch merely adds flight stability and in parafoils can help prevent tip-colapse and induce turning stability.

> Doei Diego

Ciao, -- Just fishing for angels!


Foil Design

All in regard to high performance dual and quad line buggy engines

I have read with interest all the comments and information provided on the main foil designers web pages, and it seems apparent that there is a huge swing toward thinner (15% of chord ) risers.

I also note a lack of information and discussion on minimum, maximum and average depths of the finished foil . A lot of the information available on airfoil sections relate to solid, and not inflatable planforms, so the information will be relevant to a very small proportion of a ram air foil due to billow.

From some rather basic calculations, I have found that a foil with a 17% riser will have a maximum depth when inflated of 22% and an average of 19% approx.. based on a 4:1 AR and 21 cells. adding or decreasing cells 2-3 either way makes little difference.

Should we be designing foils to give an average thickness closer to our chosen foil,or base our designs on the maximum, as this is where the most of our drag is going to come from.

Has any body out there built a 12% of chord foil ,if so please share your experience.

I think the ram air foil has had the "gauntlet thrown down to it " by the c-quad and the obvious single skin clones which will follow .With the draw backs of the c- quad becoming more apparent each day via this group, I feel we can afford to push the limit of foils and suffer the consequences of less luff resistance, gust stability and inflation stability in order to gain that extra performance, lets face it they're still going to be less hassle than c-quad.

Maybe the future is in a tribrid !! a single shaped skin with lateral stability by a spar and longitudinal stability via single ram air cells acting as spars?? Go on get that crappy old foil out the bag cut every other cell out, tape over the cross vents stick in that spar out of that old flexi and see what happens.

That's enough to be getting on with now, so back out to the workshop to breath life into frankenkite.

Igor AKA Smudge

=============================================================

Hiya, Gene Matocha wrote some excellent articles on most of the foil design issues you mentioned throughout your posting. They can be read at http://www.digitalfidelity.com/kites/

Designs using the right profile, shaped skin, bridle and cross rib support can easily minimise the difference between the designed and inflated shape as these techniques control the amount of billow. Thinner foils in most cases have less drag, better forward speed and better edge penetration improving upwind performance. The above mentioned site also has relevant link info for other sites on the same topics.

=============================================================

> Just a quick note to say the photos are finally back, and up on the web. > I can't be bothered to find the kitepics gateway right now, so here's the > address: http://www.geocities...349/photos.html >

Your kite is really awesome! Thanks for all the info you've posted about it. Your page is evolving nicely...I'll add a link next time I do an update. Keep up the good work...you're one of the cutting-edge guys for hybrids.

I must appologize to Paul (another cutting-edge hybrid guy) and others who responded to my single skin brainstorming page request. I've been busy making a foil for a friend who is moving soon, so I haven't gotten to the page.

Enjoy! Gene Matocha

=============================================================

Hi there one and all, another try.

Inspired by Simon's excellent post. This is an attempt at a simplification of the underlying principle for those who have a more pictorial type of thinking. If it doesn't work you'll tell me. If it does, great. Regard it as an introduction to Simon's earlier post and Gene's web description.

Take a square mesh net and put it over a ball. The lines radiate over the surface. Cut a slice off the ball net and all and lay it on a flat surface. Make sure your browser's set to fixed width font, you may need a big window too and you should see a squashed igloo with radial lines:-

viewed from the side.
_______
_ - * !
_ * ! __!------!
* ___!------ ! !
* _/_--- ! !_____--!
*__--/ ___!--------! !
/--___/-----__ !________!________!
x=100 x=0

This is the rudimentary "airfoil" shape. The length of material in the curved surface is obviously greater than the "footprint" it plants on the flat surface. It curves in both x and y planes with respect to z, the height. Here x is across the page and y is into it. It's these differences in length we need to calculate. For a real foil the slice won't be round but stretched out more or less and the maximum height will be offset from the centre, maybe around x = 70. It may also be double skinned. We can calculate the height "z" for every point at the intersection of the grid from it's position on the airfoil curve and span.

For example on the centre line span wise, front to back (x direction), near the nose, the curvature is most pronounced and looks from the side like this

		    /	  /\
/ 94 Foil
/ 96 thickness
/ 98 z
/ \/
!.100..................
< Chord x >

....z2
/! /\
/ !
/ ! Height = z2 - z1
...../...!
z1/\! !
!....!
Base = 2 (98-96)

The length of the sloping bit between x = 98 and 96 is the square root of (height.squared + base.squared). This is the length of one little sloping bit on the centre line of the foil. Repeat this for all the intersection points on this chord line from front to back. Repeat this for all the other chord lines on the net from front to back (as they taper off to the sides the foil thicknesses will decrease). Repeat the whole process for the other axis running across the foil from side to side (y). Add up all the little bits to find the lengths of all the lines of the net in the x and y planes and mark these on a grid on the material.

Here I've used the terms x, y and z in the conventional fashion to describe a 3d object. Don't be confused when you see airfoil coordinates expressed as x and y. "y" there is the height which I've called z. Had to call it something.

If this is any help you can get more details from Simon's previous post and Gene Matocha has a good section on skin projection too and he has some decent diagrams, not like this ascii stuff. http://www.digitalfidelity.com/kites/

Sorry about the ascii stuff, my composer wasn't set to fixed width font! Tel


Engineering

I too am an aerodynamics novice, but here is what I have figured out so far. If anyone has more/correct information (Dave Lord, for example), please share!

Hi one and all, aerodynamic novice questions,

Assuming a foil with a coefficient of moment zero, will the foil naturally strive to an angle of attack which corresponds to it's maximum lift/drag ratio? It does seem logical. If this is so then is it not best to bridle such a foil for this angle?

Not necessarily. Coefficient of moment is just a way of standardizing pitching motion. What you must realize is that it is based on torque about 25% chord. What I think is more important to us kite makers is the center of lift. Basically, a kite with 0 Cm has the center of lift at 25% chord. If the Cm is positive, the center of lift is in front of 25%, and if the Cm is negative, the center of lift is behind 25%.

Now, if you were to put a pivot at the center of lift (as you have in the above example), the foil would assume an angle of minimum drag. I think this happens to be the point where pressure distribution averages out on both sides of the foil...making the Cl 0. If you look at a few foil descriptions, this occurs at 0deg for a symetrical foil, or typically some negative aoa for asymetrical ones. The best LDR, however, usually occurs at some higher aoa.

The center of lift and the bridle point establish a very basic and crucial relationship, however. To illustrate this, let's ignore all forces except lift and the bridle point.

Lets say you have a foil with a Cm of 0. This puts the center of lift at 25% chord. The vector for the lift force is perpindicular to the centerline of the foil (this is an assumption, if anyone is positive how this vector is oriented, please let me know. It COULD always be oriented perpindicular to the direction of travel, I'm not sure). Now, if we imagine the foil as a rigid plank, and we put the bridle point directly under the center of lift (25%), then the aoa of the foil will be perpindicular to the fly lines. If the kite is very efficient and flying at the edge, it's aoa will be close to 0. If we move the bridle point forward, then the aoa will become more negative. If we move the bridle point back, then the aoa becomes more positive.

If you want to prove this to yourself, tie a 30cm string to both ends of a short (say 10cm) spar section. Now grasp the spar in the middle, and grasp the string in the middle. Pull in opposite directions. The spar will be perpindicular to your force. This is center of lift = 50%, bridle point = 50%. Now grasp the spar closer to the LE (pick an edge for your LE :) )...this is moving your center of lift more forward, or making the Cm larger. You will see the AOA increase.

There are some simple vector mathematics which can prove this, but I haven't worked them out yet. It is quite intuitive, which is probably better for this discussion.

So as a general rule, for our purposes Cm is related to the center of lift. If you move the bridle point in front of the center of lift, the resulting aoa will decrease. If you move the bridle point behind the center of lift, the aoa will increase. The trick is to put the bridle point in a position so the resulting aoa puts the foil at it's best LDR.

An interesting note here. If you have followed this so far, you will begin to understand that how far BELOW the canopy you place the bridle point effects this relationship very directly. The further below the canopy the bridle point, the LESS the aoa will change by moving the bridle point forward and back. This I believe is a very critical relationship, and there is probably room to optimize it.

While on the topic, I once asked the Aero Design Team (link on my page) how to convert Cm to center of lift...here was the reply:

ANSWER from David Saunders on February 9, 1999: Given the pitching moment for an airfoil, is there a simple way to convert it to the center of lift?

ANSWER from David Saunders and Steve Smith on February 9, 1998: The pitching moment, Cm, isn't properly defined without a moment center, Xm, say. In practice, Xm is normally 25% of the airfoil chord, but the question can be answered for any choice of Xm. Suppose the center of lift is Xc. By definition, the moment about Xc is zero and the lift can be considered to act at Xc. Then, introducing the lift coefficient, Cl, (lift per unit of chord C) we can equate moments as follows:

(Cl x C) x (Xc - Xm) = Cm x C or Xc/C = Xm/C + Cm/(Cl x C) or Xc = Xm + Cm/Cl for unit chord

Note that this fails if Cl = 0, but the center of lift for zero lift isn't defined either.

If Cm = 0, then the moment center and center of lift are equal, and for typical airfoils and physical pressure distributions, this point is found to be very close to 1/4 chord.

Now, I haven't been able to use this formula, primarily because I think I'm missing something. This is how I interpret the equation:

Let's take a known foil, the Clark Y. At 5deg aoa, it's Cl is about 1, and the Cm is about -.085. This gives us: Xc = .25 + -.085/1 = .165

This seems to imply the center of lift is at 16.5%. This doesn't seem right, since if the center of lift is in FRONT of 25%, the foil would have a POSITIVE pitching motion. It would pitch UP, but a negative Cm means it pitches DOWN.

If the equation were Xc = Xm - Cm/Cl then it would make sense...anyone know the answer? Dave, you have a clue?

Now assuming a coefficient other than zero, won't the foil be restrained in four line flying and be forced to retain this angle anyway?

Four lines definatly change the bridle relationship I described.

Is it theoretically possible to design a foil with the maximum L/D occurring at less than zero degrees, ie one that will fly upwind?

He he, this is another topic all together. There are a number of foils that have positive Cl below 0deg aoa, but they won't fly beyond the edge. I think the short answer is the forward speed of the kite is determined by a vector addition between the forces on the kite and the pull of the lines which oppose them. The forward vector comes from the lines, not from the kite. Beyond 0 deg (beyond the edge, that is), there IS no forward vector, only backwards vector.

Enjoy! Gene Matocha


AntiBanana

I've been thinking about the 'banana' effect, in relation to ram-air inflated power kites. A couple of ideas came to mind.

1) Design the shape of the kite to allow for banana - i.e. if you want a straight rectangular kite, make the trailing edge slightly wider than the leading edge, with the ribs splayed out towards the tips. As the kite inflates, and the trailing edge over-inflates, the tips will be pulled in and the kite runs 'straight'. I've used a variant of this on the 'Phaze' kite - the trailing edge is slightly wider than it should be to allow for the billow.

2) Hex-ribs. This is rather more work. Less work than the string ribs being discussed elsewhere, but still... Rather than having straight ribs running front to back, have ribs arranged in an interlocking, pseudo-hexagonal pattern across the kite. Make the hexagons smaller as you approach the leading and trailing edges, so the relationship between rib height and distance between ribs stays roughly the same.

this would look something like this : (crapscii alert)

   leading edge
-----------------------------
/ \/ \/ \/ \/ \/ \/ \/
| | | | | | | |
\_/ \_/ \_/ \_/ \_/ \_/ \_/
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/
----------------------------
Trailing edge

Now. I don't know how this would affect airflow across the kite - I suspect it would increase drag somewhat - But it might allow some tuning of which parts of the kite are at what internal pressure. This is also something I've been thinking about - If we can moderate the pressure of air at the trailing edge, we can minimise 'ballooning' and thus reduce the banana effect. And if we can maximise pressure at the leading edge, we can ensure a clean leading edge profile, and increase the efficiency of the kite. All at the expense of increased internal structure and thus more complexity and weight, though. And, on that note, how about a ram inflated 'spar' or two running the width of the kite? A sub-structure, inflated to a higher pressure than the rest of the canopy (through the use of more or larger intakes per unit volume than the rest of the kite) providing structural integrity and therefore reducing the amount of bridling required?

Possible? Not? Discuss.

Simon

=============================================================

Surely the pressure inside the foil, a static volume of air, will be the same throughout? I think you could only arrange for different pressures in different places by dividing up the structure into separate sections with separate air ports at differing positions. I.e. one at the stagnation point for maximum pressure to one section and another somewhat off to give a lower pressure for another section. It may be difficult to ensure/calculate that the pressure inside is always higher than outside for each particular section though. So unless my recall of physics is up a gum tree this isn't going to work. Correct me if I'm wrong.

With both feet firmly planted in the air Tel

=============================================================

Hi,

Great post btw. I love to see tech topics :)

A few thoughts...

Hex Ribs: A distinct possibility...infact, a discussion about hex-ribs led to Kite Tech 3 - Go with the flow. Andrew and I were discussing the drawbacks of airflow non-parallel to the chord. He said he didn't think it stayed parallel anyway, and thus there *may* be no drag penalty. Thus KTIII. Dispite KTIII, Hex ribs may not pose a drag penalty...the more I learn about turbulators, gurney flaps, LE trips (like on the aerobie), I think airflow is a fickle thing. Basically, try it. It might work. I must say, however, that banana can be successfully addressed w/o hex ribs. (HRibs?)

Non-parallel ribs: Probably quite worth while. However, before you jump into this, you need to do a bit more math. You MUST know the inflated shape. The formula on KTII will get you very close, but I've been knocking around another formula that should be even more accurate, or prove the accuracy of the KTII formula. Basically, it involves the slicing just like in KTII, but deriving a formula based on MAXIMUM VOLUME of each slice. This could be done w/ a spreadsheet, or some basic calculus. I've got almost all the pieces, I just haven't had time to put it together. If someone is willing to have a crack at it soon, let me know and I'll pass on my notes. There is another reason to make ribs non-parallel. It stems from a VERY old Horseshoe-reefing thread. Hold on to your hats...this one may be important. If your kite has anhedral, then the ribs (if perfectly parallel to each other) become progressively less parallel to the onset flow as you approach the tips. Assuming, of course, that your kite flies at a positive angle of attack. What does this mean? For minimum drag, ribs SHOULDN'T be parallel to each other, they should be perpindicular to the onset flow at the optimized AOA. POP! Also assuming of course, that ribs not parallel to the onset flow pose a drag penalty. Blown your mind yet?

Variable pressure: I'm not saying this doesn't have applications, but as long as your skin is essentially non-strechable, (considering the tiny inflation pressures, most fabrics don't stretch from those inflation pressures), then increasing or decreasing the pressure won't change the shape as long as you stay above the external pressure. Where the shape WOULD change, would be in the panels BETWEEN the chambers. Your idea of taking inflation pressure from different areas of the kite could have some awesome applications, however. I once considered designing a multi-chambered kite that would change the shape of the airfoil based on the location of the stagnation point...sort of a pressure-induced reefing...but that's yet another idea I haven't had time to try. It would also require some very accurate aerodynamics modeling (or MANY trial-and-error kites) to get right. If buggying weren't so damn much fun, I could get a lot more done. :)

Here's another tidbit for you designers: Stagnation pressure decreases as sweep increases. Consider this when making elliptical planforms.

Enjoy! Gene Matocha

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.